Promise Ring vs. Engagement Ring: What's the Difference?
It’s easy to get a promise ring confused with an engagement ring. The two styles can look quite similar, so it is a common mistake. In addition to the fact that the rings may look similar to the eye, they also share a common theme of dedication to a committed relationship. It’s important to understand the difference between a promise ring and an engagement ring because it can assist you and your significant other when making the decision to take your relationship to the next level. Here’s what you need to know about the difference between promise rings and engagement rings.
The Evolution of Commitment Rings
Commitment rings have evolved over time, with promise rings and engagement rings each playing their own roles in symbolizing love and dedication. When comparing promise rings vs. engagement rings, it’s important to understand their purposes and traditions. While both adorn the fingers of those who are in love, they represent different relationship stages.
An engagement ring is typically worn on the ring finger of the left hand and clearly symbolizes the intent to get married. Engagement rings often feature a prominent diamond or another precious gemstone set in gold, platinum or sterling silver.
A promise ring, on the other hand, can be worn on any finger on either the left or right hand. They often incorporate smaller gemstones or symbolic designs like hearts and infinity signs. Promise rings serve as a precursor to the more formal commitment of an engagement ring and are usually given earlier in the relationship.
Promise Ring Meaning: A Symbol of Commitment
Somewhat like an engagement ring, a promise ring symbolizes another’s commitment, dedication and true feelings for you. While many promise rings are given to another when a romantic relationship becomes serious, some give promise rings to loved ones or very special friends for platonic or even faith-based reasons. Traditionally though, a promise ring is a piece of jewelry given as a physical token of their love and plans to marry the other person at some point.
You might also hear the term pre-engagement ring thrown around when talking about promise rings. While you might be able to split hairs and say that pre-engagement rings and promise rings are different, they’re functionally the same thing. Any differences that they have really comes down to the individual wearers and what sort of commitment they imbue on them.
Promise rings do come in a variety of styles, though they tend to be simpler types of rings overall and are less ornate than a wedding band or engagement ring. Usually, a promise ring is just a plain band, so a solitaire stone or anything fancier is almost never seen. That said, promise rings are still new enough that the set of norms hasn’t been completely defined. If you want a solitaire stone on your promise of marriage, you’re more than welcome to do so.
That being said, the gift of a promise ring is not a proposal and should not be confused with one. It’s important to know that when someone gives a promise ring, it usually means that they intend to marry the other person, just not at that time. This could be for many reasons including age, distance, career goals or the fact that the couple would like to spend more time in a dating relationship before getting engaged. For that reason, many folks think of a promise ring as a placeholder for an engagement ring and wedding band that will come later. It’s still a symbol of love and commitment, but it’s not quite as formal or serious in most cases. Whatever the reason behind a promise ring, it always means that the person wants to give a sign of commitment to their significant other.
While the traditional values of a promise ring are widely accepted and used today, other elements of the ring allow for some unique interpretation and personalization. The specific meaning behind a promise ring is truly up to the giver of the ring. While this meaning is commonly known as the idea of intended marriage, it can be a more specific promise that rings true to the person’s relationship with another. Other unique meanings behind promise rings include abstinence until marriage, values passed down from parents to their children or even a unique promise that the wearer makes to themselves.
One way to personalize your promise ring is through the materials used to make it. There are relatively no hard and fast rules when it comes to what a promise ring should look like. Though these rings commonly include colored gemstones, birthstones and varied designs, they usually look different than a traditional engagement ring (without a center stone to differentiate between the two). Popular promise rings might include a symbol like a heart (like our “Sweetheart” ring) or infinity symbol, but it’s most important to choose a design that represents who you are!
Unlike engagement rings and wedding rings, promise rings tend to be worn on the right hand. Of course, you can wear a promise ring on your left hand if you like, but that may cause confusion to others. Granted, it’s your ring and your relationship, so you don’t have to concern yourself too much about the perception of others if that doesn’t bother you.
The symbolism behind promise rings and engagement rings extends beyond their placement on the hand. Engagement rings have a long-standing tradition of featuring a diamond as the center stone to symbolize enduring love and commitment. However, modern couples increasingly opt for engagement rings with colored gemstones, adding personal significance and unique flair to this timeless symbol.
Promise rings, while less bound by tradition, often incorporate birthstones or other meaningful gemstones to represent the couple’s connection. The design of these rings varies greatly, from simple bands to more elaborate styles, but they typically lack the prominent center stone characteristic of engagement rings. This distinction in design is one of the key factors in the promise ring vs. engagement ring debate and helps visually differentiate these symbols of commitment.
Engagement Ring Meaning: Love and Marriage
Unlike a promise ring, an engagement ring’s meaning doesn’t have any wiggle room. An engagement ring symbolizes a person’s desire to have the other’s hand in marriage. The giving of an engagement ring marks the starting point of planning a wedding and spending the rest of your life with the love of your life.
While promise rings are typically worn on the right hand, an engagement is primarily worn on the wearer’s ring finger. Though ring fingers can differ by country or region in the world, wearing a metal band with some type of stone on your ring finger will usually have people assuming it’s an engagement ring.
The cultural significance of engagement and promise rings varies worldwide, influencing how and where they are worn. In many Western cultures, the engagement ring is traditionally worn on the ring finger of the left hand. However, in some European countries, the engagement ring goes on the right hand. When it comes to promise rings, there’s more flexibility. While many choose to wear a promise ring on the right hand to avoid confusion with an engagement ring, others stick with the left hand, seeing it as a precursor to the engagement ring that will eventually take its place. After marriage, the engagement ring is often paired with a wedding ring on the ring finger of the left hand to create a set of wedding rings that symbolizes the couple’s journey from engagement to marriage. Sometimes, a promise ring remains as part of the stack. In other cases, though, it gets moved to a different finger or stored as a keepsake.
Another major difference between a promise ring and an engagement ring is physical appearance. Traditional engagement rings are rather unmistakable in appearance, featuring a silver or gold band and one or more diamonds, usually with a larger stone in the center. While there are numerous styles and diamond shapes within the engagement ring category, these rings usually follow a general guideline.
Like most rules and traditions, some like to break the mold and try something different. Nowadays, there are many different styles of engagement rings, including silicone bands, colored gemstones and unique styles. You don’t have to break the bank when shopping for a ring either. For those with a smaller ring budget, there are affordable engagement rings in multiple styles and sizes you’ll love. No matter your preference, there is an engagement ring out there for everyone.
The Promise of Forever
Despite their different meanings, appearances and intentions, both engagement rings and promise rings symbolize something that is meant to last. They’re unique and deliberate signs of commitment between two people. They are beautiful physical reminders of your own values or someone else’s love for you, and Modern Gents has the perfect option for everyone.